← All posts

Why "it depends on the year" is the most honest answer in tax

Your client wants a yes or no. Why does your best answer start with "it depends"?

Clients hear "it depends" as hedging. Tax professionals know it is often the most accurate thing they can say. Limits change by year, temporary provisions expire, and some changes reach back to returns already filed. The trick is to say "it depends" and then actually resolve it, for that client and that year.

Turning "it depends" into a clear answer at a glance

What the client asksWhat it depends onWhat to tell them
"Can I deduct this?"Tax year, facts, income level"For your return for that year, yes, up to this amount."
"Will this still work next year?"Whether the rule is temporary"It applies through a set year. After that, it is scheduled to change."
"My friend got a different answer"Different year or facts"Their answer may be right for their year. Here is yours."
"I read online that…"When that article was written"That was true before the change. Here is the current rule for your year."

Why year-specific answers build trust

  • They show you checked. An answer with a year and a source signals real work.
  • They prevent surprises. Clients are less upset by a rule change they were warned about.
  • They set up the next conversation. "This expires after that year" opens a planning discussion.

How to say "it depends" well

  1. Name what it depends on, in one line. Usually the tax year, a date or an income level.
  2. Resolve it immediately for this client's situation.
  3. Give the source in plain words. "This comes from a specific section of the Code, effective for that year."
  4. Flag what could change, such as a temporary rule or pending IRS guidance.
  5. Write it down, so the next preparer gives the same answer next year, or knows why it changed.

What to avoid

  • Stopping at "it depends" without an answer.
  • Giving an answer with no year attached.
  • Quoting a number from memory without checking whether it changed.

Frequently asked questions

Do clients get frustrated by "it depends"? Only when it ends there. Followed by a clear, year-specific answer, it reads as expertise.

How do we explain temporary provisions? State the years they apply to and what is scheduled to happen after. Avoid predicting whether they will be extended.

Should we put the tax year in client emails? Yes. It protects the client and the firm if the email is reread years later.

How Factagora.tax helps

Factagora.tax is AI tax research for any tax year. It answers for the tax year you specify, with the primary authority and its effective date, so "it depends" becomes a clear answer your team can explain and record.

Want to see it on your own client questions? Get early access. Early access is free.

Get early access

We're inviting the first 50 firms ahead of the 2027 filing season. Early access is free.

Free during early access. No credit card. Invites go out weekly.

By signing up you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.